Published on

March 8, 2025

Office Printer vs MFP: Which Device Fits Your Needs?

Table of Contents:

Subscribe to newsletter

Thank you! Your submission has been received!

Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form.

Choosing between an office printer and a multifunction printer (MFP) depends on your business needs. Here's a quick summary to help you decide:

Office Printers: Focused on high-quality printing. Compact, affordable, and ideal for low-volume tasks or small teams. Limited to printing only.
Multifunction Printers (MFPs): Combine printing, scanning, copying, and faxing in one device. Better for high-volume tasks, workflow automation, and shared office spaces. Higher upfront cost but lower per-page expenses.

Quick Comparison

Feature	Office Printer	Multifunction Printer (MFP)
Core Functions	Print-only	Print, scan, copy, fax
Cost Per Page	Up to $0.30 for color	$0.065–$0.075
Space Requirements	Compact, desk-friendly	Larger, shared spaces
Security Features	Basic network security	Advanced secure printing
Maintenance	Harder to repair	Easier to repair
Price Range	$250–$3,000	$600–$16,000

Key Takeaway: If you need simple printing for a small team, go for an office printer. For more features, higher volume, or integrated workflows, an MFP is the better choice.

Printer Buying Guide: Ink vs. Laser / Tank vs. Subscription

Features: Printers vs MFPs

Standard Printer Features

Modern office printers are designed to deliver dependable, high-quality prints. They often come with features like network connectivity, double-sided printing, and basic security settings. Their simple setup and compact size make them a good fit for personal workspaces, and they typically require minimal training to operate. However, they are limited to basic printing tasks, unlike multifunction printers (MFPs), which offer a broader range of capabilities.

MFP Features and Functions

Multifunction printers (MFPs) go beyond printing to include scanning, copying, faxing, and more. For example, the RICOH 132 can handle a monthly workload of up to 35,000 sheets. MFPs also come with advanced tools like:

Customizable interfaces: Platforms like Toshiba's Elevate let users tailor the MFP's interface, making frequently used functions easily accessible.
One-touch operations: Multi-step tasks can be saved as single-button commands, simplifying complex workflows.
Third-party integration: MFPs can connect with various business apps, improving document management and collaboration.

Feature Comparison Table

Here’s a side-by-side look at the main differences between office printers and MFPs:

Feature Category	Office Printer	Multifunction Printer
Core Functions	Print-only	Print, scan, copy, fax, and email
Interface	Basic control panel	Customizable touchscreen with app integration
Security Features	Standard network security	Enhanced options like secure print release
Setup & Training	Quick setup, minimal training	More setup time, detailed training required
Document Management	Basic print queue management	Workflow automation and document storage
Integration Options	Limited network connectivity	Broad compatibility with third-party apps
Paper Handling	Standard trays	Multiple trays and advanced finishing options
Monthly Duty Cycle	Lower volume capacity	Higher volume (e.g., 35,000 sheets for RICOH 132)

Choosing between a standard printer and an MFP depends on your office needs. Standard printers are ideal for straightforward printing tasks, while MFPs offer a more versatile solution for managing documents and improving workflow efficiency with their integrated features.

Cost Breakdown: Printers vs MFPs

Purchase and Setup Costs

The initial cost of a standard printer versus a multifunction printer (MFP) depends on features and printing capacity. For smaller teams (up to 5 people) printing about 1,200 pages a month, color printers typically range from $500 to $3,000. On the other hand, enterprise-grade MFPs designed for heavy-duty use can range from $7,500 to $16,000.

Here’s a breakdown of costs by business size:

Business Scale	Print Volume	Device Type	Price Range
Small/Home Office	Basic	Printer	$250 - $600
Small/Home Office	Basic	MFP	$600 - $1,200
Medium Business	5,000/month	Commercial MFP	$4,500 - $9,300
Large Business	10,000/month	Commercial MFP	$7,500 - $16,000

Once you’ve considered the purchase price, it’s important to factor in ongoing costs to fully understand the value of each device.

Running and Repair Costs

Operational expenses, including supplies, maintenance, and support, can account for 1-3% of a company’s total revenue. For example, the Canon imageRUNNER DX 4945i black toner cartridge costs around $125 and yields 44,500 pages. Color cartridges for the Advance DX C5800 Series cost between $370 and $400, with yields of 60,000 to 71,000 pages.

Total Cost Comparison

When you combine purchase and operational costs, the per-page expense becomes a key metric for comparison. Here’s a look at some common devices:

Device Model	Black Print Cost	Color Print Cost
HP Color LaserJet Pro MFP 3301fdw	3.1¢	17¢
Brother Wireless HL-L2460DW	2.8¢	N/A
Brother MFC-L3780CDW	2.5¢	12.9¢

Laser printers generally offer better long-term value, with average costs of 6 to 8 cents per page for both black and color prints. This is significantly lower than inkjet printers, which can range from 10 to 20 cents per page. For businesses with high-volume printing needs, commercial MFPs, despite their higher upfront cost, are more economical due to lower per-page expenses and reduced maintenance requirements.

Key Considerations for Cost Management

According to Gartner, 90% of business leaders are unaware of the total costs associated with their printer fleets. To make informed decisions, consider the following:

Monthly printing volume
Color versus black-and-white usage
Maintenance agreements
Energy efficiency and consumption
Security-related expenses

To manage costs effectively, look for devices with features like auto-duplexing and energy-saving modes, which can help cut operational costs. High-capacity toner cartridges are another way to reduce per-page costs, especially for businesses with heavy printing demands. By evaluating these factors, you can choose the right device to meet your business needs while keeping expenses under control.

sbb-itb-f0f0986

Space Use and Office Impact

Space Requirements

When planning an office layout, it's important to account for the size and clearance needs of your devices. For example, a floor-standing MFP like the Xerox AltaLink C8170 takes up significant room, with base dimensions of 24.4" x 31.2" x 46" and a hefty weight of 352 pounds.

Device Type	Typical Dimensions (W x D x H)	Weight
Desktop Printer	16" x 7" x 6"	5–15 lbs
Small MFP	20" x 20" x 25"	50–100 lbs
Floor-Standing MFP	24" x 31" x 46"	300–400 lbs

On top of the device's footprint, you'll need extra clearance for smooth operation, maintenance, and supply replacements. Maximizing space efficiency while ensuring high performance is key to keeping workflows productive.

Work Speed and Process Impact

High-volume MFPs are game-changers for busy offices, delivering print speeds of 100 to 136 pages per minute. Features like cloud archiving, mobile printing, user-friendly touchscreen controls, and automated scanning workflows simplify tasks and allow for multitasking. These tools help streamline daily operations, saving time and effort.

Power Use and Green Options

Energy efficiency and eco-friendly features are also crucial when choosing office equipment. Devices with ENERGY STAR certification, for instance, consume up to 35% less energy than standard models. Here are some noteworthy stats:

The average office worker uses around 10,000 sheets of copy paper each year.
Nearly 45% of printed pages are discarded the same day.
Between 10% and 35% of printed pages are never even picked up.

Feature	Impact	Implementation
Sleep Mode	Cuts energy usage; ENERGY STAR models save up to 35% energy	Enable sleep mode during inactivity periods
Duplex Printing	Reduces paper usage significantly	Set duplex printing as the default setting
Secure Print	Prevents waste from uncollected documents	Use user authentication for print jobs
Cloud Integration	Reduces reliance on paper with digital workflows	Use cloud services for document management

"Benefitting from the energy efficiency of an ENERGY STAR certified product means paying less and reducing the greenhouse gas emissions of your imaging equipment purchase at the same time." – Ryan Fogle, ENERGY STAR Certified Products

Selecting Your Office Device

Office Needs Checklist

Start by assessing your printing habits: how much you print, the types of documents, and any security concerns. For instance, a law firm dealing with sensitive information might need secure printing features, while a marketing agency would benefit from high-quality color printing for client presentations. Conducting a print audit can help identify these requirements.

Business Need	Printer Option	MFP Option
Low Volume (<1,000 pages/month)	Desktop Printer	Small MFP
High Security	Personal Desktop Printer	MFP with Secure Pull Printing
Color Marketing Materials	Color Inkjet Printer	Color Laser MFP
Document Processing	Basic Printer + Scanner	Integrated MFP Workflow

Compare the cost per page of each option with your monthly print volume to find the most budget-friendly choice. Also, think about how well the device can adapt to your growing needs and whether it integrates smoothly with your current systems.

Planning for Growth

Your office needs will evolve, so choose solutions that can grow with you. Keep these points in mind:

Leasing options and managed print services that adjust as your needs change
Regular software updates to maintain compatibility with new systems
Expandable paper capacity for handling larger print volumes

Connectivity Options

Strong connectivity can significantly improve productivity. Depending on your office setup, these are some connection options to consider:

Connection Type	Best For	Key Advantage
Ethernet	Large Offices	Reliable network printing
Wi-Fi	Flexible Workspaces	Easy mobile access
Cloud Printing	Remote Teams	Print from anywhere
NFC	Quick Access	Tap-to-print convenience

Matching Devices to Your Needs

Choose devices that align with your business requirements:

Standard Printers Work Well For:

Small businesses printing less than 1,000 pages per month
Departments needing dedicated printers
Offices focused on document confidentiality
Basic black-and-white printing tasks

MFPs Are Ideal For:

Healthcare facilities managing patient records
Law firms handling extensive documentation
Insurance agencies processing claims
Marketing teams producing diverse materials

For a more tailored solution, consider partnering with a Managed Print provider. They can assess your organization's specific printing needs and recommend whether consolidating devices into a single MFP could streamline your workflow and save costs.

Summary and Next Steps

Main Points Review

When choosing between a standard printer and a multifunction printer (MFP), keep these key factors in mind:

Decision Factor	Standard Printer	MFP
Initial Investment	$200-800	$1,000-5,000
Space Requirements	2-3 sq ft	4-6 sq ft
Monthly Volume	Up to 3,000 pages	Up to 20,000 pages
Energy Usage	300-500W	900-1,500W
Best For	Single-function needs, small teams	Multi-department collaboration

Your decision will depend on your workflow and budget. Standard printers are ideal for straightforward printing tasks in smaller setups. On the other hand, MFPs are better suited for offices that need a device capable of handling diverse document-related tasks.

Making Your Choice

Follow these steps to make an informed decision:

Evaluate Your Needs: Take note of your current usage, expected workload, and the space available in your office.
Analyze Costs and Energy Use: Look at the cost per page and energy consumption to ensure the device aligns with your budget.
Consider Workflow and Security: Think about how the device will integrate into your existing processes and whether it meets your security requirements.

If you're short on space, a standard printer is likely the better option. MFPs, however, require additional clearance for maintenance, so plan accordingly.

For expert advice, consult a print solutions specialist. They can provide a detailed assessment to help you identify cost-saving opportunities and choose the best device for your needs.